The Favoritist: Don’t be THAT boss!

Everyone wants to feel valued at work, but when a boss starts playing favorites, things can go south fast. The Favoritist Boss singles out certain employees for special treatment while others feel like they’re stuck in the shadows. Let’s take a look at why playing favorites is bad news for your team and how to lead more fairly.

Why Favoritism is a Problem

Favoritism can quietly (or not so quietly) destroy a team's dynamic. Here’s why playing favorites as a boss is one of the worst things you can do:

Kills Team Morale: When some employees are consistently praised, promoted, or given the best opportunities while others are left behind, it creates an “us vs. them” environment. People start to feel undervalued and disengaged, which tanks morale.

Breeds Resentment: Favoritism fosters resentment, both toward the favored employee and the boss. Team members who feel overlooked might stop putting in effort, knowing their hard work won’t be rewarded the same way as the “favorite’s.”

Lack of Trust: Once favoritism is obvious, trust in leadership takes a nosedive. If employees feel you’re not fair or objective, they’ll question all your decisions—and may even stop coming to you with ideas or concerns.

Undermines Collaboration: Teamwork relies on everyone feeling like they have a role to play and a fair shot at recognition. If one person is getting all the credit, collaboration starts to break down, and soon enough, everyone’s just out for themselves.

How to Avoid Being the Favoritist Boss

Be Objective: Make decisions based on performance, not personal feelings. Use clear, measurable criteria for promotions, raises, and rewards. This way, everyone knows what’s expected, and no one feels like someone else is getting an unfair advantage.

Acknowledge Everyone’s Contributions: Go out of your way to recognize the efforts of all team members. A simple “thank you” or shoutout during meetings can go a long way in making people feel appreciated.

Offer Equal Opportunities: Make sure that all employees have access to growth opportunities, whether it’s a new project, leadership training, or a chance to take on more responsibility. Everyone should feel like they have a fair shot at advancing.

Avoid Cliques: It’s natural to have better rapport with some team members than others, but make sure your personal preferences don’t impact professional decisions. Treat everyone equally in terms of workload, opportunities, and attention.

Foster an Inclusive Environment: Encourage collaboration and create a culture where everyone feels like they belong. Make sure all voices are heard and respected, especially during team discussions.

Favoritism is a fast track to a fractured team. As a leader, it’s your job to create a fair and balanced environment where everyone feels valued. By recognizing contributions, offering equal opportunities, and keeping your personal preferences in check, you can avoid the pitfalls of favoritism and build a stronger, more cohesive team. Don’t be THAT boss who plays favorites—be the one who lifts everyone up.

Feeling stalled out? Want a jump start? Schedule a free career strategy session: https://calendly.com/northdawncoach/career-strategy-consultation